Training

Pull-ups vs lat pulldown: which is better for your back?

Both train the lats through the same movement. The better choice depends on your strength level, your goal and how precisely you want to load the back.

Pull-ups and lat pulldowns train the same muscles — the lats, upper back and biceps — through a very similar vertical pulling motion, and research comparing them finds similar muscle activation. For building muscle, both work well. Pull-ups are harder to scale but train the whole body to stabilise and are excellent for relative strength; the lat pulldown is easier to load precisely, lets beginners train before they can do a pull-up and makes it simple to add small increments. Most lifters benefit from including both.

What each exercise does well

Pull-ups:

• Move your own body through space, which demands core and shoulder stability


• Build relative strength — useful for climbing, gymnastics and many sports


• Need only a bar, so they work at home and outdoors


• Can be loaded with a belt once bodyweight reps become easy

• Load can be set below your body weight, so beginners can train the movement with good form


• Small weight increments make progression smoother


• Easier to control the tempo and reach a deep stretch at the top


• Easy to vary grip and use single-arm versions

Which is better for muscle growth?

When effort and number of hard sets are equal, growth is similar. What matters more is training close to failure with a full range of motion, and adding reps or load over time. If you can do only 3–4 pull-ups, the pulldown lets you get more quality reps in the 8–15 range, which can be more productive for hypertrophy at that stage.

How to use both

• Can't do a pull-up yet: lat pulldown 3 × 8–12, plus negative pull-ups or assisted pull-ups 2–3 sets.


• 5–10 pull-ups: pull-ups first for 3–4 sets, pulldown later in the session for 2–3 sets of 10–15.


• 10+ pull-ups: weighted pull-ups for 3–6 reps, pulldowns or single-arm pulldowns for higher reps.

Technique tips for both

• Start each rep by pulling the shoulder blades down, not by bending the elbows.


• Pull the elbows down toward your ribs; think "elbows to back pockets."


• Bring the chest toward the bar or handle rather than craning the neck.


• Lower all the way to straight arms for the full stretch.


• Avoid leaning far back on the pulldown; a slight lean is fine.

Does grip matter?

Wide, shoulder-width, neutral and underhand grips all train the lats. Underhand and neutral grips involve the biceps more and usually allow more reps. Choose the grip that feels best on your shoulders and change it every few months for variety.

FAQ

Will lat pulldowns help me do my first pull-up?
Yes, especially combined with negative pull-ups and assisted pull-ups. Being able to pulldown around your body weight for a few reps often coincides with the first strict pull-up.

Are pull-ups better for back width?
Not inherently. Back width comes from lat growth, which both exercises provide.

How many sets per week?
Around 10–20 hard sets of back exercises per week, split between vertical pulls like these and rows, works well for most people.

More articles

How to build a bigger back: width, thickness and a sample plan Cracking joints: when clicks and pops are nothing to worry about How to gain weight if you're skinny and have a small appetite How many calories does weight training burn? Shoulder pain when benching: common causes and fixes Short sleep during a diet means losing more muscle and less fat How to build a bigger chest: exercises, sets and a sample plan Alkaline water will not change your body's pH or your performance